Duval Street · Key West, FL

Take Home a Piece of the Southernmost Point — Not Another Plastic Souvenir

Curated gifts, local artistry, and island finds that actually tell the story of Key West. Every shelf is hand-picked so you walk out with something worth keeping.

Explore Collections Find Us on Duval

Interior of Christmas In Paradise gift shop on Duval Street

Curated selection of Key West souvenirs and gifts

Local art and handmade items at the shop

Our Story

Rooted on Duval, Crafted for the World

Christmas In Paradise sits at the heart of Key West's most iconic street — and we treat every item on our shelves like it belongs there. We source from local makers, Caribbean artisans, and island suppliers who understand what makes this place irreplaceable.

Locally Sourced, Globally Shipped

Every product is selected for authenticity. If it doesn't feel like Key West, it doesn't make the cut.

Built for Travelers Who Care

We know you've been burned by mass-produced trinkets before. Our inventory is different — and you'll feel it the moment you walk in.

Gifts Ready for Any Occasion

Birthday, anniversary, or "I just got back and need to send something to Mom" — we've got you covered.

Collections

What You'll Find Inside

Six categories, one standard: everything here is worth bringing home.

Key West themed home décor and coastal decor items

Home & Coastal Décor

Handcrafted pieces that bring the Southernmost Point into your living room — driftwood art, shell accents, and hurricane lamps.

Bestseller

Key West apparel and island-themed clothing

Apparel & Accessories

From breathable linen shirts to hand-stamped silver jewelry — wear the island with you wherever you go next.

New Arrivals

Local Key West art and handcrafted items

Local Art & Handcrafts

Direct from Key West artists — prints, sculptures, and one-of-a-kind pieces you won't find at the airport.

One of a Kind

Curated gift sets and souvenir collections

Gift Sets & Bundles

Pre-curated collections for every budget — from a simple keychain to a full island experience in a box.

Gift Ready

Key West themed drinkware and bar accessories

Drinkware & Bar Essentials

Tiki mugs, engraved tumblers, and cocktail gear that turns any kitchen into a Key West tiki bar.

Fan Favorite

Kids toys and family souvenirs from Key West

Kids & Family Finds

Age-appropriate island toys, educational items about Key West history, and keepsakes the whole family will love.

Family Pick

Why Christmas In Paradise

The Difference Is in the Details

Anyone can sell souvenirs. We make sure every purchase feels intentional — from the moment you walk in to the package you carry out.

Hand-Selected Inventory

Every item passes a simple test: would we gift this to someone we actually care about? If not, it doesn't make it to our shelves.

Convenient Duval Location

Right on the main drag — easy to find, easy to pop into before or after your evening on Duval. We're open seven days a week.

Knowledgeable Staff

Our team lives here. We'll help you pick the right gift for the right person — not just the most expensive thing on the shelf.

Fair & Transparent Pricing

No tourist markup tricks. What you see is what you pay — quality gifts at prices that respect both you and the makers.

Quick & Easy Shopping

Whether you have 10 minutes between drinks or an hour to browse, our layout is designed for a smooth, stress-free experience.

Supporting the Local Economy

Every purchase stays in Key West — supporting local artists, makers, and the community that makes this island special.

Visitor Stories

What People Say After Visiting

Real feedback from travelers who stopped by Duval and left with something meaningful.

"I walked in not knowing what to buy and walked out with five perfect gifts. The staff actually listened to who I was buying for instead of pushing the most expensive stuff."

Maria K. Chicago, IL

"Finally, a Key West shop that doesn't feel like a tourist trap. The local art is genuinely beautiful, and the prices are honest. This is the place I come back to on every trip."

James R. Austin, TX

"Bought a driftwood frame and a set of hand-painted coasters for my parents. They still talk about how special those gifts feel. Thank you for making it easy to find something real down here."

Sarah L. Denver, CO

Get in Touch

We'd Love to Hear from You

Questions about a specific item, bulk orders, or just want to say hi — reach out however is easiest for you.

Address

119 Duval St
Key West, FL 33040-6505

Phone

(305) 587-4054

Email

southernmostpointgiftshop@gmail.com

Hours

Open 7 days a week
Visit us anytime during business hours